September 2011
1 tag
iamclearlyawizard asked: I know I'm a little behind the times, but at any point in the new Phyrexia development did you consider crossing over the phyrexian mechanics. I mainly mean a living weapon with infect. But were any of the other phyrexian mechanics considered for a cross-over?
Sep 1st
1 note
August 2011
1 tag
hardwired-artificer asked: So for cards that turn cards face down such as Ixidron, what do you do for double-faced cards?
Aug 31st
3 notes
1 tag
destindigi asked: There have been mechanics that turn cards face down, flip them, had them dropped over the table and even ripped up(in Unglued). It seems that with double faced cards all physical uses of a Magic card have been attempted for mechanics and abilities. Do you believe there are still design opportunities in the physical features of the cards themselves?
Aug 31st
3 notes
1 tag
drsylvan asked: I'm remaining cautiously optimistic about double-faced cards, but I'm curious to hear your thoughts on how new players will understand the mechanic. It seems like the least beginner-friendly thing since Future Sight, or maybe phasing, just due to the logistics---does R&D have some secret weapons to make this more accessible?
Aug 31st
1 note
1 tag
pseudolias asked: Why are the white ghosts/spirits benevolent while the blue ones are malevolent?
Aug 31st
1 note
2 tags
Aug 31st
84 notes
1 tag
luminumcan asked: Spirits/Geists don't seem to be counted as a "monster" type. Some of the previewed Spirits we have seem Human-friendly, while others seem malevolent. What led to this decision, rather than making them just a fourth kind of monster?
Aug 30th
2 notes
1 tag
eternalcheechako asked: When a stranger asks you what you do, about what percentage of the time do they know what magic is?
Aug 30th
1 note
1 tag
segoli asked: Have you got any thoughts concerning the Gizmodo article from a woman who dated Jon Finkel (google "my brief okcupid affair with a world champion magic the gathering player" if you've not seen it)? What do you do to combat the potential social stigma associated with the admittedly very nerdy hobby of playing Magic, and what can players do with regard to diminishing that stigma?
Aug 30th
10 notes
1 tag
eternalcheechako asked: Did you guys watch any specific horror movies for source material?
Aug 30th
1 tag
eternalcheechako asked: So there is now a human lord. Kinda. Did he happen in design or development? How big a battle was it to get him printed?
Aug 30th
3 notes
1 tag
eternalcheechako asked: How are there any white flip cards white since none of the monsters are in white?
Aug 30th
2 tags
Aug 30th
11 notes
1 tag
hardwired-artificer asked: How hard was it to get double-faced cards to happen? They seem like they might be more of a hassle to try and use than not; but cool nonetheless. Also, why was it decided to use this new mechanic instead of re-using flip cards?
Aug 30th
3 notes
1 tag
injusto asked: First, let me tell you I can't wait to play at the Innistrad pre-release to try the new Mechanic X. After this I would like to know what kind of measures did you take for the coming days of "Maro is destroying MTG with these flipcards!!!"?
Aug 30th
3 notes
1 tag
sarroth asked: I'm very excited to see new enemy-colored dual lands. How do they fit in Innistrad, considering the tribes are all allied-colors?
Aug 30th
1 note
1 tag
eternalcheechako asked: What is the solid colored circle on the left side of the type line on the backs of double faced cards?
Aug 30th
1 note
1 tag
eternalcheechako asked: What was the playtest name of "Ludevic's Test Subject/Abomination"?
Aug 30th
1 tag
absol-lutely asked: when i draw a double faced card am i obligated to show the back of it to my oppenent if he or she asks?
Aug 30th
2 notes
1 tag
destindigi asked: What happened to the little tombstone that used to be on flashback cards?
Aug 30th
1 tag
foxerbeta asked: Now with the double faced cards... is there any chance of a Legendary Creature transforming on a Planeswalker and/or vice versa?
Aug 29th
7 notes
1 tag
segoli asked: Does every double-faced card have the same artist for each face?
Aug 29th
3 notes
"Every Two Sides Has a Story" →
The design if Innistrad is a little more revolutionary than most. Have no idea what I’m talking about? Go read this article. Have an idea? Also, go read this article.
Aug 29th
3 notes
1 tag
chahmtg asked: For the creature type Werewolf, was Lycanthrope ever a consideration? Or even a new word like Lycant. One side could be Lycant Human and the other side a Lycant Wolf.
Aug 29th
2 tags
Aug 29th
22 notes
2 tags
Aug 26th
22 notes
1 tag
thelastfayth asked: Mr. Rosewater: Can you tell the day when you of the site are going to reveal the mechanics of Innistrad?
Aug 25th
2 notes
2 tags
pixelador asked: Not sure if this has been asked already, but what do you use to put your Tales from the Pit comics together?
Aug 25th
2 tags
Aug 25th
5 notes
1 tag
hymntotourach asked: Are all of the questions from "Another day of R&D productivity lost" TftP comics based on actual questions that R&D members ask and try to answer?
Aug 24th
2 tags
Aug 24th
14 notes
1 tag
benapplegate asked: In this new era of top-down block design (woohoo!), how involved is Creative in the early stages of a set?
Aug 24th
1 tag
aljones15 asked: Magic sets are usually epic, have you ever considered a set centered on a few people and a small space especially in light of the planes walkers? I feel like the smaller physical space and emphasis on a few key characters would change the nature of design radically.
Aug 24th
1 tag
mibnub asked: It appears that a lot of Innistrad's (and also other horror theme's) story is brought out by the night or moon, does this mean Innistrad is boring during the day, and that all the excitement is reserved for the night, or is there still depth/action to the story even during the day?
Aug 24th
2 tags
Aug 23rd
23 notes
1 tag
eternalcheechako asked: Do you even look at a specific color and CMC and think, "we need something there"? Or is that the realm of development? On an unrelated note, we need another white 3-power flier for 3. Flickerwisp is lonely. (The other three cards weren't designed for me)
Aug 23rd
1 tag
eternalcheechako asked: Why are previews starting this week? Do we get four weeks of previews for some reason?
Aug 23rd
2 tags
Aug 22nd
12 notes
"State of Design 2011" →
Once a year, I look back at the previous year of design and give my opinions as the Head Designer. How did the Scars of MirrodinĀ (and more) block do in my opinion? Check out the article. Also, I give some teases about what to expect in Innistrad.
Aug 22nd
7 notes
1 tag
trompinha asked: Are the Commander (the previously unreleased ones) cards Modern legal?
Aug 21st
1 note
1 tag
jumboto asked: Do you still make magic puzzles/riddles similar to the ones found in Magic the Puzzling? Personally I'd love to see a second volume of the book.
Aug 21st
2 notes
1 tag
mibnub asked: Is your State of Design article really coming next week? Seem's a little early this year compared to last years at least.
Aug 20th
1 tag
tehpoker asked: Dear Mr. Rosewater, you are the Magic Head Designer, you're the author of a weekly column, you're married and have kids. And on top of that, you claim to read every single email, post, tweet and tumblr message that goes your way. My question is how do you manage all that?
Aug 20th
5 notes
1 tag
thrutimeandspace asked: How many questions go unanswered? :(
Aug 20th
1 tag
eternalcheechako asked: For those of you who have the access, which is the go to reference: Gatherer or Multiverse?
Aug 20th
1 note
2 tags
Aug 19th
5 notes
1 tag
mibnub asked: Does R&D intentionally try to make at least one angel in every set coming out from now on?
Aug 19th
4 notes
1 tag
injusto asked: Who would win? Eldrazi or Phyrexians?
Aug 19th
5 notes
1 tag
eternalcheechako asked: On what occasions is lunch provided for you guys?
Aug 18th
1 note
2 tags
Aug 18th
16 notes