Blogatog

Month

June 2013

So, no four-color creatures, I get that. But since (at least from the looks of it) the largest audience for such a thing is Commander players, why not do three-color creatures with an off-color ability? Would that fall into the same problems?

I didn’t say we’d never do a cycle of legendary creatures. I just said it would be difficult. We do difficult things all the time.

Jun 19, 20135 notes
Mark, I just wanted to say I love the blog and the you're weekly podcast, and playing magic. As a follow up to my Chandler question, when will Magic finally have kangaroos?

I’ll get a jump of it. : )

Jun 19, 20134 notes
Do you think it's unfortunately awkward that Magic is aimed at an age group with limited spending capabilities?

I think you misunderstand who Magic is aimed at.

Jun 19, 201317 notes
You mentioned in your podcast about planeswalkers an initial design where they would be "stupid" doing a certain action each turn in a certain order... I'm really interested in the concept of such a card. How likely is that we will see that design in some artifact, or in a new kind of card? (Contraptions ;)?)

As they are “close to planeswalkers but not quite”, I think the chances are low but not impossible.

Jun 19, 20133 notes
I see that the Renton Community Foundation poster is once again plastered on the side of Renton City Hall. Always good to see the "Wizards" logo as a sponsor. It's nice to use a product from a company that supports the local community.

Wizards (and Hasbro) is big on supporting the local community.

Jun 19, 20135 notes
Referencing a question from a few days ago, if squee were to return as a planeswalker, would he be just as difficult to get rid of?

Let’s call that a “big if”.

Jun 19, 20132 notes
Will we ever see a return to Rabiah (Arabian Nights)? Djinns & Efreets are sweet.

I think we’ll see djinns and efreets again but a return to Rabiah’s a 10 on the Storm Scale, mostly because nowadays we tend to do inspired worlds rather than straight up ports of real mythologies.

Jun 19, 20133 notes
Jun 19, 201342 notes
#Magic The Gathering #MTG #Tales from the Pit
Where should I go to submit card designs? (I know this has probably been asked before, but I have no idea)

The only time we’ve set something up for submitting directly to us gas been the various versions of “You Make the Card” and the second Great Designer Search.

Jun 19, 201310 notes
Tribal tournament: Which creature type would you use and why? Also, which creatures win the tournament?

I would probably use Ooze. Just remember I’m a die-hard Johnny.

Jun 19, 201315 notes
When asked in your City Mail article, you gave the mechanics that you would reuse for each guild, why did you choose frenzy over devour for Gruul? As much as frenzy feels Gruul, devour just seems so much more flavorful.

Both could work. I just personally felt frenzy would work with their play style better.

Jun 19, 20136 notes
Was Smart Ass and its cycle all top-down design?

The designs were made to match the names so it was top-down in that regard.

Jun 19, 20133 notes
Do you think that MMA failed as a product when more than half of the cards are utilized by Commander players?

Lots of people playing the cards is seldom a sign of failure.

Jun 19, 201321 notes
Are you coming to Amsterdam this summer? If so, i just might stop by to thank you in person (if that's ok).

I am coming to Amsterdam. That and San Diego Comic-con are my two Magic trips this year.

Jun 19, 20133 notes
Since, Theros was code named "friends", what are the odds of Chandler being reprinted?

About the same as a card named “Joey” being in the set. : )

Jun 19, 201325 notes
When Path to Exile was named, did R&D already know that "remove from the game" was changing to "exile"?

Nope, that was not known at the time. We were aware of “Path to Exile” though when we chose the word “exile”.

Jun 19, 201310 notes
Silver-bordered rules question: Does R&D's Secret Lair prevent from me from using Richard Garfield, Ph.D's ability to play a card as a different card with the same cmc?

No, Richard Garfield PhD still works just fine.

Jun 19, 20131 note
Who is Fog "for?" Is it just there (ie., a staple in core sets) because it teaches a lesson about card evaluation? (Yes, this card looks really powerful-- and it is-- but in most situations cards that get you closer to winning are better than cards that keep you from losing.) Is it a tool for Johnnies to build "Turbo Fog" type decks? Tradition? What's the reasoning when R&D decides that a set needs Fog or a fog effect?

Just because a card isn’t tournament caliber doesn’t mean lots of players don’t play it. Fog, as an example, is a very popular card in casual play.

Jun 19, 201314 notes
My girlfriend and I are avid EDH fans, and I play it nearly exclusively. We're wondering if WotC would ever consider printing four color legendary creatures that just so happen to fit into the current Standard set? We thought maybe that something like the Nephilim would be printed in RTR, but no dice :( TL;DR: We don't know the design limitations on creating creatures in four colors, especially at rare or mythic.

Four-color cards, legendary or no, are problematic in that it’s hard to capture the flavor of four different colors. Nephilim, our one attempt to date, didn’t go over very well (the major reason they didn’t come back this block).

Jun 19, 201311 notes
What is Magic's stance on rolling dice? Do you try to stray away from it as much as possible, and if so, why? Is there some principle of game design that makes you not want to include it much, or does it just not fit into Magic as a game very well?

Dice are problematic in a skill-based game because they are icons of randomness. Their presence tends to frustrate many players. (I talk about this in my article on randomness.)

Magic messed around with six-sided dice in Unglued (with mixed success). I don’t know if dice will ever make it to black border.

Jun 19, 20138 notes
Next page →
2012 2013
  • January
  • February
  • March
  • April
  • May
  • June
  • July
  • August
  • September
  • October
  • November
  • December
2011 2012 2013
  • January
  • February
  • March
  • April
  • May
  • June
  • July
  • August
  • September
  • October
  • November
  • December
2011 2012
  • January
  • February
  • March
  • April
  • May
  • June
  • July
  • August
  • September
  • October
  • November
  • December